Despite valiant efforts to come up with an alternative approach, pop-ups still infest the web. It seems like every site you visit wants you to sign up for a newsletter, take advantage of an offer, visit a sponsor, or provide feedback—all before you’ve actually reached the content you arrived to see.
The value of the pop-up to designers is obvious: a piece of information that doesn’t need to be on screen all the time, doesn’t need to displace other more permanent elements of the design; creating its own window gives it temporary space, and the required prominence, without interrupting the rest of the layout.
Pop-ups can easily be dismissed, often simply by clicking anywhere but on the pop-up. Psychologically they partition content, allow for competition entries, logins, and the like, to be focussed on for a short period of time. Pop-ups also neatly side-step the issue of opening new windows, maintaining a single session and preventing users from passively navigating away from a site.
But pop-ups are also intrusive. They’re a lot like a waiter that tries to take your order before you’ve taken off your jacket. They’re easy to apply to a site with minimal disruption, but easy solutions are rarely good solutions.
Usability testing tends to show that users dislike pop-ups—closing them as soon as possible—but that they also tend to understand them, perhaps because they mimic the basic UI of the OS.
With usability so high on everyone’s agenda, did pop-ups simply evolve at the right time? Are they a stable design pattern, or a particularly persistent design trend?
Ben Moss
Read Next
The Power of the Human Face in Web Design
First impressions online are made in just a few seconds, so nailing your web design is crucial. Among the many elements to play with, one stands out for its universal…
The Dangers of Deceptive Design Patterns (And How to Avoid Them)
Yet the rise of UX dark patterns, or deceptive patterns as they are more often referred to, poses a significant challenge to maintaining an ethical and user-centric approach in the…
The Art of UX Writing
Today, we will discuss some essential tips and best practices to elevate your UX writing, ensuring it resonates with users and aligns with sound design principles. Whether you’re a seasoned…
How To Write a UX Case Study That Wins More Work
To maximize your chances of landing a job or client, including information about your work in a case study is essential. This article provides some practical tips on what to…
7 Secrets of Designing an eCommerce Website
When done right, design isn’t just visual — it’s experiential. It can engage, captivate, and guide users through a curated journey. From the moment they land on your page to…
Unlocking the Power of Design to Help Users Make Smart Decisions
UX, from a decision-making perspective, means focusing on a user’s context and individual needs. How does the immediate decision fit into the user’s broader goals? What is influencing their decision?…